Summary a comprehensive result but suggested a small effect

Summary week 2 – Martine maand

Developmental effects of visual environment on species-assortative
mating preferences in Lake Victoria cichlid fish

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Bram Spierings | 950620790080 | Frontiers in Biology | 18-01-18­




Speciation is the formation of distinct species
within the course of evolution. Geographical changes, barries (allopatric) or
sexual selection (sympatric) are examples of factors which are the driving
process behind speciation. Previous studies indicate that sympatric speciation
could be driven by heterogeneous environments when geographical obstacles are
missing. An example of sympatric speciation in a heterogeneous environment is
the sensory speciation in two species of Chichlids in Lake Victoria. Two
closely related Chichlids, Pundamilia
nyererei and Pundamilia pundamila
live in the same lake but differ in preference of waterdepth, and thus light
intensity. Both species behave as ‘real’ species when they are present in their
prefered habitat but hybridize in turbid habitat where.


State of the art

Although the aquatic ecosystem shows evidence in
visial communication, reproductive isolation due to visual adaptation hasn’t
been proved yet. Previous research to the effect of changing visual conditions
on mate choice for killifish did not show a comprehensive result but suggested
a small effect of sensory development on color choice. This promissing
suggestion is why the link between visual system properties and visual mate
preferences should be further investigated.

Another study has found that p. nyererei expresses higher long-wavelength-sensitive visual
pigment and is more sensitive to red colors compared to P. pundamila. Furthermore, the characteristics of male coloration,
photic environment and female preferences are correlated with the visial
systems which the Chichlids prefer. Botch Chichlids species and their
crossbreeds are used in this experiment. The Chichlids were reared under
simulated red colored deep- (turbid) and blue colored shallow (clear) water
conditions. Afterwards the preference of females for red or blue males under
different light settings was tested.


Recent findings

Female preference was significantly
affected by the rearing light conditions. Quiver and courtship behaviour for P. pundamila and P. nyererei
was prefered by both deep and shallow reared females however P. pundamila was more in favor by
females which were reared in simulated shallow water habitat. The female
Chichlids which were reared in deep water habitat did not have a specific
preference for any of the male Chichlids species.  Furthermore, when female species are brood in natural habitat
circumstances there is a significant interaction between rearing light and
lateral display and quiver. Female chechlids do more frequently respond to males
of the same species in reared lighting than when they are reared in artificial
lighting. Whenever P. pundamila
was raised in shallow water the females preferred males of the same species but
when P. pundamila was raised in deep
water it did not. P. nyererei did not
have any preference for either red or blue males in either shallow- or deep
reared habitat. When both P. pundamila and
P. nyererei are combined in one group
and are re-organising to the natural and unnatural deep and shallow lake rearing
conditions, it turned out that non random mating occurd. Sexual selection for
quivering male chichlids with the same phenotype occured significantly more
often than that females wanted to mate with a male with a different phenotype. It
turned out that females which were reared in light conditions that simulated
their natural habitat preferred mating with males who have similar phenotype females
preferred but did not have a preference for any phenotype when brood under
unnatural light circumstances.